Planning law

Building on a gap plot without a development plan: section 34 BauGB

In planning law, a plot with no development plan (Bebauungsplan) may be built on if it lies within a continuously built-up part of a town or village and your project meets every condition of section 34 of the Building Code (BauGB), above all fitting in with its surroundings and having secured access. The building authority decides with the municipality; a preliminary decision (Vorbescheid) gives certainty before you buy, and state building rules and other public-law rules apply as well (section 29(2) BauGB).

On this page

Built-up area or outer area: where section 34 applies

Section 34 BauGB needs a "continuously built-up part of the municipality" (im Zusammenhang bebauter Ortsteil), and both halves of the phrase must be met. For the Federal Administrative Court (Bundesverwaltungsgericht), two things are needed. The group of buildings must be numerous enough to carry some weight and form an organically grown part of the settlement. And it is continuous only as far as the buildings, despite gaps, still look like one closed, connected whole (ruling of 30 June 2015, 4 C 5.14, para. 11).

Being surrounded by houses is not enough: the plot itself must share that impression (para. 13). Larger open land inside a town that does not take part is outer area (Außenbereich) in planning law, even with houses all around, and section 35 BauGB applies; see building in the outer area.

Only visible structures with some weight count as buildings here, as a rule those used by people permanently. Temporary buildings and ancillary structures serving a farming, gardening or other main use will as a rule not shape a built-up area (para. 15).

Where a simple development plan exists, for instance one fixing only building lines, sections 34 or 35 govern whatever it leaves open (section 30(3) BauGB); see zoning and buildability check.

Fitting in: four criteria, each with its own surroundings

Inside the built-up area a project is allowed in planning law if it fits in with the character of its immediate surroundings (nähere Umgebung) and access is secured (section 34(1) sentence 1). The four criteria:

  • Type of use: housing, shop, workshop, office.
  • Scale of use: how large and how tall.
  • Building pattern (Bauweise): for example open, with side gaps as detached, semi-detached or grouped houses, or closed, with none (section 22 of the Land Use Ordinance, BauNVO).
  • Area to be built over: where the house stands, such as its distance from the street and depth into the plot.

The surroundings are defined separately for each criterion (Federal Administrative Court, order of 13 May 2014, 4 B 38.13). They take in the area the project could affect and the area whose buildings shape, or at least influence, what may be built on the plot.

A project fits in if it stays within the range its surroundings set, unless it lacks due consideration for the buildings right next to it. Outside that range it may still fit in by exception, but only if it is not liable to create or increase planning conflicts in the area (bodenrechtlich beachtliche Spannungen), either itself or through similar projects it could encourage (ruling of 8 December 2016, 4 C 7.15, para. 17).

Plot ratio without a development plan: how scale is judged

A site coverage ratio (Grundflächenzahl, GRZ) is something a development plan fixes (section 16(2) BauNVO). Without one, the project fits in by scale if nearby reference buildings are comparable when footprint, storeys and height are weighed together, in open development also the ratio to open space. Matching on one factor alone is not enough (4 C 7.15, headnote 2).

With the assumed values from the diagram: mostly two-storey houses of 105 to 140 m² and 8 to 9.5 m, plus one three-storey house of 180 m² and 11 m. A two-storey house of 130 m² and 9 m has models here. A three-storey building with a 250 m² footprint has none, because only its storey count matches; whether it may still fit in turns on whether it would cause such planning conflicts.

Access, living conditions, townscape and shopping areas

Access (Erschließung) must be secured; see access and infrastructure. Healthy living and working conditions must be kept and the townscape not impaired (section 34(1) sentence 2). No harmful effects on central shopping areas in the municipality or elsewhere may be expected (section 34(3)).

The building authority decides under section 34(1), (2) and (3a) in agreement with the municipality (Gemeinde), which may refuse only on grounds from those provisions. If it does not refuse within two months of receiving the authority's request, agreement counts as given; where state law requires filing with the municipality, that filing counts as the request (section 36 BauGB).

Section 34(2): when the area matches a standard zone

If the surroundings match a zone type of the Land Use Ordinance, such as a general residential area, the type of use is judged only by whether the ordinance generally allows it there (section 34(2)); section 1(2) BauNVO lists the zones. In a general residential area, homes are generally allowed, guest accommodation only by exception (section 4 BauNVO). For uses allowed by exception, section 31(1) applies by analogy, otherwise the exemption rules of section 31(2) and (3) sentence 1; conditions: section 31 BauGB. Scale, pattern and area built over must still fit in under section 34(1).

Departing from the fit-in test: section 34(3a) and (3b)

Under section 34(3a) a departure in an individual case is possible only if all three conditions are met:

  1. It serves extending, altering, changing the use of or renewing a lawfully built commercial or craft business; extending, altering or renewing lawfully built buildings where this creates new homes or makes housing usable again; or converting a lawfully built structure to residential use, including any alteration or renewal this requires.
  2. It is justifiable in urban planning terms.
  3. It is compatible with public interests, neighbours' interests included.

It does not apply to retail businesses that may harm local shopping provision or central shopping areas. In the two housing cases it also works for several comparable cases if the other conditions are met and no development plan is needed.

Section 34(3b) covers new residential buildings: with the municipality's consent, the fit-in test may be departed from in one or several comparable cases if the project is the construction of a residential building and is compatible with public interests, neighbours' interests included. Consent is needed even where the municipality is itself the building authority; it is given if the project matches the municipality's ideas on urban development and may carry conditions. If not refused within three months of the authority's request, consent counts as given; a public comment period of up to one month extends this (section 36a BauGB). For the other tools of the same law, see Bau-Turbo, section 246e.

Municipal by-laws: section 34(4) to (6)

A municipality may fix by by-law (Satzung) where its built-up area ends and may combine the three (section 34(4)).

On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.

By-laws under section 34(4) BauGB
By-law, s. 34(4)What it doesConditions and procedure
No. 1, Klarstellungssatzung (clarifying)fixes the boundaries of the built-up areanone from s. 34(5); announcement as under s. 10(3)
No. 2, Entwicklungssatzung (development)declares built-up parts of the outer area built-up areasshown as building land in the land-use plan (Flächennutzungsplan); all three conditions of s. 34(5) sentence 1; consultation and announcement (s. 34(6))
No. 3, Ergänzungssatzung (infill)adds single outer-area plots to the built-up areashaped accordingly by the built use next to them; all three conditions of s. 34(5) sentence 1; also s. 1a(2), (3), s. 9(1a), statement of reasons; consultation and announcement

The three conditions for nos. 2 and 3 apply together; wording in section 34(5) sentence 1. Such by-laws may contain individual provisions under section 9(1), (3) sentence 1 and (4).

Ask the municipality whether a by-law covers the plot and get text and map; it takes effect on announcement (section 10(3) BauGB by analogy). An outer-area by-law under section 35(6) is different: projects there remain section 35(2) projects.

Certainty before you buy: the preliminary decision

Whether a house fits in is the authority's assessment. A preliminary decision (Vorbescheid) makes it binding: before a full application, the building authority rules on specific questions, such as admissibility in planning law. Each state's building code governs it, so validity, documents and fees follow state law. In Bavaria:

  1. Frame the question. Parcel, cadastral district (Gemarkung) and planned use, footprint, storeys, height and position; ask about each criterion separately. Applicant and qualified designer (Entwurfsverfasser) sign (Art. 64(4) with Art. 71 sentence 4 BayBO).
  2. File it. In writing with the building authority (Art. 64(1)); the lower building authorities are the district-level administrations unless the task has been transferred to a municipality (Art. 53 BayBO). Completeness is checked within three weeks (Art. 65(1)).
  3. Neighbours and municipality. Neighbour participation under Art. 66 BayBO can be waived for a Vorbescheid on application (Art. 71 sentence 4). The municipality takes part under section 36 BauGB, or section 36a for section 34(3b).
  4. Ask about time and fee. Art. 71 sets no decision deadline; the building authority gives processing time and fee if you ask before applying.
  5. Note the validity. Four years unless the decision sets another period, extendable on written application by up to four years at a time (Art. 71 sentences 2 and 3).

For Brandenburg see building permit and pre-application; other states set the rules in their own building codes. The notary can tie the purchase to a positive Vorbescheid, for example through a right to withdraw (notary process and closing).

Even without a plan, the municipality can resolve to draw one up and protect it with a development freeze (Veränderungssperre, section 14(1) BauGB), or on the conditions of section 15(1) have a decision suspended for up to twelve months. Ask whether a plan is being drawn up.

How it looks in the report

The sample report for a plot in Brühl-Badorf, North Rhine-Westphalia, shows the official parcel boundaries over an aerial photo 500 m wide.

Page 11 of the Brühl-Badorf sample report: aerial photo with official parcel boundaries across 500 m, parcel 2550 marked in red
The frame holds 261 fully visible parcels; the median one is about 590 m² (aerial photo and data: Geobasis NRW, dl-de/zero-2.0, retrieved 10 November 2026). Page 11 of 112 of the public sample report dated 10 November 2026 (Brühl, Badorf district, parcel 2550), page 7 of the chapter PDF. Open this page in the sample.

The page shows boundaries and the buildings visible in the aerial photo, not a decision on whether the plot is part of the built-up area.

Checklist to print

  • □ Ask the municipality about a development plan, a section 34(4) by-law, a resolution to draw up a plan and any development freeze
  • □ Note the neighbouring houses: use, storeys, height, footprint, distance from the street, depth
  • □ Check whether the plot itself is part of the built-up row or borders larger open land
  • □ Apply for a Vorbescheid with exact dimensions and note its validity

For your plot, the GrundCheck report shows the official boundaries of neighbouring parcels on an aerial photo and the development plans in the state register, where the state publishes this data; missing data is marked. It does not decide whether or what you may build. The land register and the register of building encumbrances are not included. Order a report for a plot.

Editorial team: GrundCheck. Checked: 12 November 2026.

Official sources, accessed 12 November 2026

Common questions

Can I build without a development plan?

In planning law, yes, if the plot lies within a continuously built-up area and the project meets all conditions of section 34 BauGB: it fits in by type and scale of use, building pattern and the area built over, access is secured, healthy living and working conditions are kept, the townscape is not impaired and no harmful effects on central shopping areas are expected. In the outer area, section 35 BauGB applies instead. State building regulations apply in both cases (section 29(2)).

Which plot ratio applies without a development plan?

As a rule there is no fixed site coverage ratio (GRZ) then; only a by-law under section 34(4) no. 2 or 3 may contain individual provisions. The authority compares the project with buildings nearby by footprint, storeys and height taken together, and in open development also the ratio to open space; matching on one factor alone is not enough (ruling 4 C 7.15). A project outside that range may fit in by way of exception only if it is not liable to create or increase planning conflicts in the area, either itself or through similar projects it could encourage. Due consideration for the neighbouring buildings is also required.

Is every space between two houses a gap plot?

No. A gap plot under section 34 BauGB is an unbuilt but buildable plot that does not break the impression that the buildings around it form one closed, connected whole. A plot that is merely surrounded by buildings but does not itself share that impression is outer area if no development plan applies (ruling 4 C 5.14).

How long is a Vorbescheid valid?

That is set by state law. In Bavaria it is valid for four years unless it sets another period, and may be extended on written application by up to four years at a time (Art. 71 BayBO). In other states the period and any extension are in that state's building code.

Keep reading

Check this on your own property

The GrundCheck report organises public sources, visible risks and open professional questions for the parcel you confirm.

Check a property

Limits of this service

This service provides an automated pre-purchase check only. It does not establish ownership, title, buildability, construction permissions or service connections. It does not replace legal advice, a survey, advice from a surveyor or engineer, or tax or investment advice. Coverage is available across Germany, with data differences between state services.